Wednesday 30 December 2009

A recent uproar was sparked when a comment was publicly made by a member of the British National Party, about Chickenshed theatre company using a black actor to play the character Pinocchio in this years Christmas production. This comment left me asking the question is this just prejudice racism? Or does the colour of Pinocchio’s skin affect the show s performance?


Putting my own views and thoughts on the matter to one side, I tried to see why people would think any different to my own views. The one conclusion that I came to was people don’t like to see something they already know interpreted differently. I believe in some peoples cases, that they have seen a version of Pinocchio, for example Walt Disney’s and believe that every Pinocchio should be interpreted exactly the same.

However my opinion on the matter, is that having a black Pinocchio instead of a white Pinocchio does not affect the performance in any way. I believe the performance quality is due to the actor and not the colour of the actors skin. Chickenshed interpretation of the story is different to Walt Disney’s as well as the colour of the puppet, yet why did this not spark a debate? Leading me to the conclusion, in my opinion, that the issue of Pinocchio being played by a black actor instead of the traditional white actor was a truly racist and prejudice way in thinking.

3 comments:

  1. Lauren

    Really interesting topic - can you source that British National Party quote? Has this issue come up before in other theatrical productions? If so, would there be others from a theatrical background to back up your point of view?

    What do others think about this issue?

    Paula

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Lauren

    i agree with both Ellie and Paula about expanding on the BNP and also getting some quote's about the piece they have written about have a black actor playing Pinocchio. i think maybe you should some quotes from Chickenshed on how they feel about what people think about there work and what they feel about what the BNP said about the show. but all in all this is a really good topic to look at as it can make people think and start to question the matter for them selfs. i think if you add these things in to the piece i think it will make your piece more stronger and will give it more of a back born to back up some of things you have put in to the piece

    Murat

    ReplyDelete
  3. sorry Back Bone not Born my mistake sorry about that

    Murat

    ReplyDelete